Eat & Drink
Dining
A food scene that surprises, from local pizzerias to international flavors
A Pleasant Surprise
For a small college town, Indiana has a dining scene that consistently impresses. The combination of a permanent local population, a revolving student body, and a growing food culture means there's more variety here than you might expect. Philadelphia Street and Oakland Avenue are the main corridors, with restaurants ranging from quick deli counters to full-service Italian and Thai.
The prices are reasonable, the portions are generous, and many of the restaurants are locally owned, which means your dining dollars stay in the community.
Local Favorites
9th Street Deli
901 Philadelphia St · $
A beloved Indiana institution. Fresh sandwiches, deli favorites, and a casual atmosphere that's been keeping locals fueled for years.
Visit websiteToms Pizza & Restaurant
11 S 7th St · $
Classic local pizzeria with a full menu. A go-to for families and a staple of the Indiana dining scene.
Visit websiteCannella Cafe
660 Philadelphia St
A downtown coffee shop and cafe on Philadelphia Street. Perfect for a morning espresso or an afternoon break while exploring the borough.
Visit websiteSit-Down Dining
Donatello's Restaurant
791 Philadelphia St · $$ - $$$
Italian cuisine in an elegant setting. One of the top-rated restaurants in Indiana, popular for date nights and special occasions.
Visit websiteJosephine's Pizzeria & Enoteca
1037 Philadelphia St · $$ - $$$
Wood-fired pizzas, Italian plates, and a curated wine list in a stylish downtown setting. A newer addition that's quickly become a favorite.
Visit websiteTeerak Thai Restaurant
895 Wayne Ave · $$ - $$$
Authentic Thai flavors that consistently earn top ratings. A hidden gem that draws diners from across the county.
Visit websiteHoss's Steak & Sea House
1198 Wayne Ave · $$ - $$$
A regional steakhouse chain with a solid salad bar and hearty portions. A reliable choice for family dinners and celebrations.
Visit websiteCasual Eats
Romeo's Pizzeria & Mediterranean Kitchen
1112 Oakland Ave · $$ - $$$
Pizza meets Mediterranean in this popular Oakland Avenue spot. Gyros, stromboli, and a wide menu that keeps students and locals coming back.
Visit websiteTres Amigos Mexican Restaurant
1540 Oakland Ave · $$ - $$$
Colorful, lively Mexican restaurant with generous portions and a full bar. A popular gathering spot on weekend evenings.
Visit websiteBruno's Italian Restaurant
1108 Philadelphia St · $$ - $$$
A long-standing Italian restaurant and bar in the heart of downtown. Classic Italian-American dishes in a casual atmosphere.
Visit websiteThe Coney
642 Philadelphia St · $$ - $$$
A downtown bar and grill with a loyal following. Burgers, wings, and a welcoming vibe for casual meals and evening drinks.
Visit websiteWant More Recommendations?
Sheri knows the local dining scene inside and out. Whether you're looking for a specific cuisine or just want to know where to go on a Tuesday night, she's happy to share.